MBBS SAQ · Psychiatry
Major depressive disorder — diagnosis, suicide risk and first-line management
NEET-PG / INICET SAQ on MDD: SIGECAPS threshold, severity grading, suicide risk, SSRI initiation and review, CBT, ECT indications, and bipolar exclusion.
On this page
Study tools
Exam tags
Write your answer
Saved on this device. No marking — you are the marker.
Question
A 34-year-old primary-school teacher is brought by her sister after 6 weeks of pervasive low mood, loss of interest in teaching and hobbies, early-morning wakening (3 a.m.), reduced appetite with 4 kg weight loss, impaired concentration, fatigue, and excessive guilt that she is a "failure as a mother." She has had passive thoughts that "life is not worth living" but denies a plan, intent, or means. She drinks 2 units of wine on weekends, takes no regular medication, and has no history of elevated mood, psychosis, or previous psychiatric admission. Examination: BP 118/74, HR 78, afebrile, thyroid exam normal, no focal neurology. Thyroid function, glucose, FBC, and B12 are normal. Outline diagnosis, severity, risk assessment, and management. [1]
Model answer
Show the model answerShowHide
Diagnosis: major depressive disorder (MDD), single episode, moderate-to-severe, without psychotic features. She meets the threshold of ≥5 SIGECAPS symptoms for ≥2 weeks, including both depressed mood and anhedonia, with functional impairment. There is no prior manic/hypomanic episode, so this is unipolar (not bipolar). Organic mimics (hypothyroidism, anaemia, B12 deficiency) have been excluded.[1]
SIGECAPS present: Sleep (early waking), Interest (anhedonia), Guilt, Energy (fatigue), Concentration, Appetite/weight, Psychomotor not stated, Suicidal ideation (passive). Depressed mood is additional. [1]
Severity: Moderate-to-severe — marked functional impairment at work/parenting, vegetative features (early waking, weight loss), and suicidal ideation. Not mild (no pure watch-and-wait). Not psychotic (no delusions/hallucinations). Not catatonic. [1]
Suicide risk assessment (mandatory at every contact):
- Ideation: present, passive ("life not worth living")
- Plan / intent / means: denied — currently lower acute intent, but risk is dynamic
- Protective factors: sister support, employment, children, help-seeking
- Risk factors: guilt, hopelessness themes, female sex with perinatal-age stress, recent functional decline
- Document capacity, safety plan, means restriction (medications/alcohol), and next review timing
- Red flags for urgent escalation: active plan, psychosis, severe self-neglect, postpartum harm thoughts, access to lethal means [1]
Immediate management — stepped care:
- Psychoeducation — illness model, delayed antidepressant effect (4–6 weeks), early side effects, when to seek help.
- Psychological therapy — offer CBT (or IPT); first-line for moderate depression alone or combined with medication.
- Pharmacological first-line — start an SSRI, e.g. sertraline 50 mg once daily (or escitalopram 10 mg OD; fluoxetine 20 mg OD). Prefer sertraline for relative safety in overdose and broad evidence base.[2]
- Review at 1–2 weeks for suicidality, adherence, and early adverse effects (GI upset, activation, sexual dysfunction, hyponatraemia risk later). Full efficacy assessed at 4–6 weeks; if partial response, optimise dose before switching.
- Continue effective antidepressant for at least 6–9 months after remission for a first episode; longer if recurrent.
- Lifestyle — sleep hygiene, activity scheduling, alcohol reduction, social support.
- When to escalate — no response after adequate trial → switch SSRI/SNRI or augment; ECT if severe, psychotic, catatonic, life-threatening refusal of food/fluid, or high suicide risk not controllable as an outpatient.[3]
Disposition: Can usually manage as outpatient with close review if risk remains passive, sister can support, and safety plan is agreed. Admit if risk escalates, support collapses, or severe self-neglect develops. [1]
Common errors
- Missing the 2-week / 5-symptom threshold, or diagnosing dysthymia (needs ≥2 years).
- Not excluding bipolar before starting an antidepressant (can switch into mania).
- Starting an antidepressant without a suicide risk assessment and early review plan.
- Expecting full response in days; not warning about the 4–6 week lag.
- Using a TCA first-line in a patient with suicidal ideation (higher overdose lethality).
- Forgetting CBT as a co-equal first-line option with medication.
- Not planning continuation therapy after remission (high early relapse risk). [1]
Examiner notes
- Reproduce SIGECAPS and the diagnostic threshold cleanly.
- State a concrete drug + dose + route + review interval.
- Name ECT indications even if not indicated in this case.
- Link risk assessment language to plan / intent / means / protective factors.
- Mention postpartum and elderly modifiers if asked as variants (irritability in adolescents; somatic presentation in elderly; screen bipolar history carefully postpartum). [1]
References3ShowHide
- [1]McCarron RM, Shapiro B, Rawles J, Luo J. Depression. Ann Intern Med, 2021.PMID 33971098
- [2]Mutz J, Vipulananthan V, Carter B, Hurlemann R, Fu CHY, Young AH. Comparative efficacy and acceptability of non-surgical brain stimulation for the acute treatment of major depressive episodes in adults: systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMJ, 2019.PMID 30917990
- [3]Cipriani A, Furukawa TA, Salanti G, et al. Comparative efficacy and acceptability of 21 antidepressant drugs for the acute treatment of adults with major depressive disorder: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Lancet, 2018.PMID 29477251